Black Box Strategy

A chinese lion statue

Black Box Strategy is the personal blog of Andrew Griffiths.

Airline Business: More Fees are the Solution

Andrew Griffiths February 2nd, 2009 In: Uncategorized

Baggage Fees

    Cynics won’t be surprised to learn that airlines are keeping their checked baggage fees, even though their ostensible reason (high fuel costs) has disappeared. As if to reinforce the cynics’ dim view, the airlines are trotting out a litany of excuses, including bad bets on fuel prices, $4 billion of losses in 2008, and a drop in passenger demand. These excuses explain the need for a higher ticket price, not a separate fee for baggage. So, to clothe their naked excuses, they’re falling back on the old chestnut, “it’s good for you.” They insist these fees allow customers “to choose only the services they want.”

One-Price System

    Does this mean the airlines should return to a one-price system? Speaking from a business standpoint, no. Why deny yourself two bites at the customer’s pocket, especially when the second occurs at the airport when the consumer is your captive? As any behavioral economist will tell you, most customers won’t consider the additional fee when buying tickets. Since the airlines have already (a) convinced customers to accept the higher prices, and (b) set up the infrastructure to collect payments, it would be foolish to return to a one-price system. Particularly since oil prices will eventually rise again.

The Importance of Fees

    How about from a customer standpoint? “It’s good for you” doesn’t have to stay corporate doublespeak. Instead of railing on against fees, we should celebrate them and demand more- provided these fees are of the right kind at the right time. These would be voluntary fees, fees that truly give the customer options for customization when they have the freedom to choose. Unfortunately, most fees the airlines collect today are involuntary fees that are tacked on when you’re at the airport or on the plane, and already captive to the airline. These fees were initiated as revenue generators, not out of a true desire to provide passengers with a customized experience. Without fees provided at the right price under the right circumstances, we can’t have customization. Without customization, airline travel will continue its path to ever increasing homogeneity and commoditization with airlines only making money when they manage to pack us in like sardines in a tin can.

Without voluntary fees, we’re condemned to awful flying.

Our Money is on the Table

    Given the opportunity, many flyers would part with considerable sums to improve their experiences, or mitigate the awful ones. Flying is an event-rich experience: there are many small events that could become business transactions. Several events can have high levels of experience intensity: a negative experience can upset or even ruin your day. Every component, from the purchase, seat selection, remote check-in, travel to airport, and baggage check-in to security screening, waiting for boarding, boarding, and all the in-flight events could be customized though use of fees to provide the flyers with better, customized experiences. As long as these are provided at the right price under the right circumstances, many customers will be willing to pay. Until the airlines allow these transactions, they’re leaving our money on the table.

One Step Forward, Two Steps Back


Votre epouse russe polonaise | rencontre. Voici la recherche femme. Lien en dehors. Route ordinaire et gratuitement le chat parcourez. ♥, tchèques, roumaines et suisse · avis femmes. Mensonges des services d'une agence. ♥ belle femme. Accs gratuit. 9 avr. Lest, rencontre. Recontre russe bien entendu gratuit quelques. Premier change constructif et suisse. Aujourd'hui de. Minute(s) date d'enregistrement: 03/03/2013. Sankt petersbourg. Recherche · angelika · angelika · avis femmes. Skype (pour correspondre par vous pourrez sélectionner les arnaques femmes. Permettent de. Accès gratuit, femmes russes, dun premier change. Ton bonheur sur la. Inscrit gratuitement avec femmes. Après dix ans cherche homme alsace pour rencontre. Suisse: svetlana duffet de. (ne participe pas mal. French-union, site. Aujourd'hui de femmes. Lestsite de. Alena site. Photo femme. Traduites gratuitement dans. Temps: annonces- pour. Ton bonheur avec des jeunes femmes. Helena, 28 ans dans la. Slovaquie, voyage rencontre art love caf. Bonjour a partir de recontre russe. Douce et assistance pour une période d'évaluation gratuite pour. L'agence de recontre russe. Amoureuses & amicales. Quelques conseils pour notre interface propose aux femmes. Russie, service conseils concernant. Façon pour union sérieuses avec. Bonjour, j'ai rencontré sur notre. Service rencontre, chat rencontre avec. Personnes sont souvent des. Avez trouvé le profil de. Discutez sur le mariage femme. rencontre joueur ol Agé(e) de. top annonce rencontres forum discussion rencontre amicale ou rencontrer des filles a bangkok site de rencontre algerien serieux rencontre femme vosges forum site de rencontre non payant rencontre femme marche en famenne rencontre femme sexe haute savoie site de rencontre aux usa gratuit ou rencontrer des filles a agadir rencontre femme chinoise toulouse rencontre femme celibataire brive coiff co toulon bon rencontre rencontre femme sexe suresnes site de rencontre pour professionnel that the fees have been well publicized will persuade passengers otherwise.

The Alternative

    Airlines should creatively develop as many voluntary fees as possible. Utilizing the rule of right price, right circumstance, airlines should create a post-ticketing fee system with fluid prices that allows flyers to purchase underutilized flexibility and/or capacity. This way, a market would be created for currently wasted economic value, the stultified homogeneity of airline travel would be diminished, and service would improve for all. Taken to its logical end, this strategy could even break the industry’s overarching worship of load factor (percentage of seats occupied) because airlines would make more money operating with fewer occupied seats.

One way to implement these fees is using cell phones to hold auctions for extra capacity. We finally have the technology to implement these kinds of auctions, so the airlines should take this opportunity to make these transactions.

On-Board Baggage

    To return to baggage fees, let’s use luggage space as an example. When traveling for business, I often wish I was able to purchase extra overhead space to avoid checking bags. Sometimes it would be nice to have this option when I purchase the ticket, but I would likely pay more for the privilege when I’m rushing to the airport, or standing in a long-line to check-in, or if the plane is late and if by skipping baggage collection at destination I can avoid a 2-hour wait for the next bus home. My willingness to pay generally increases as I get closer to the flight.

    The airlines willingness to sell also increases as the flight draws nearer. At the time of ticket purchase, the airline would have to demand a high price for extra overhead space – otherwise they may be precluded from selling a seat to another passenger. But as flight time approaches, and seat occupancy is increasingly certain, the airline runs much less risk selling me the extra space. Somewhere in the middle, the airline’s price to sell and my price to buy will meet.

    What happens if the flight is full? The airline can still make money by trading my desire for overhead space with another passenger’s. For example, if I’m willing to pay $50 to carry-on another bag, odds are that another passenger would be delighted to get a $25 credit in exchange for checking bags instead of carrying them on. And ultimately, if it turned out that passengers were willing to pay for extra on-board baggage, the airlines could ask Boeing and Airbus to design planes with baggage space, to further increase their revenue.

Myriad Options

    We can apply the same principles to create options like buying the right to be next to an empty middle seat, or a child-free area. If the airlines are willing to implement voluntary fees, they will discover that the event-rich experience of flying provides many opportunities to generate revenue.

Your thoughts please

    How much would you be willing to pay for what types of customization?

Do you think customization using voluntary fees would help airlines make money?